New Tool Estimates Looming Risk of Kidney Failure in People with Kidney Disease
Study in JAMA validates and extends internationally a risk calculator initially developed in Canada
An online tool combining results of common medical tests can accurately estimate the risk of whether someone with chronic kidney disease will develop kidney failure in the next two to five years, an international team of researchers led by the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health has found.
Reporting in the Jan. 12 Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA), the researchers say the new calculator will not only help patients at high risk for kidney failure prepare for dialysis or transplant, but could provide peace of mind to millions more who have chronic kidney disease but are not at serious risk of kidney failure. The tool was developed with the support of the National Kidney Foundation.
Researchers estimate that 10 percent of the U.S. population – more than 20 million people – has kidney disease and more than 660,000 people have kidney failure requiring either dialysis to mechanically clean the blood or a kidney transplant. In 2013, 117,000 patients developed kidney failure, meaning that approximately 1 percent of those with chronic kidney disease develop kidney failure every two years.
“This tool allows doctors to sit down with their patients and explain how likely it is that their kidneys will fail in the near future,” says Josef Coresh, MD, PhD, the George W. Comstock Professor of Epidemiology at the Bloomberg School, and head of the Chronic Kidney Disease Prognosis Consortium, which conducted the study. “While the tool can aid in management of a patient’s disease and prepare them for the worst, many more patients will find the results reassuring. You can reassure a lot of worried people with the fact that their risk is actually very low. The vast majority of patients will not need dialysis.”
Building on a tool created by Canadian researchers studying Canadian patients, the Consortium validated the tool using data from more than 721,000 people in 30 countries. They found that a four-variable risk calculator accurately predicted the risk of kidney failure in two or five years, and an eight-variable calculator did moderately better. The four-variable risk calculator uses age, sex, an estimate of kidney function based on a blood test and the amount of protein in the urine, while the eight-variable risk calculator adds blood calcium, phosphate, bicarbonate and albumin levels. The second set of laboratory tests isn’t as widely done in clinical practice as the first.
The researchers found that the results in the United States were similar to those in the original Canadian study. They also found that, in countries outside North America, the risk tool needed slight adjustment to account for the lower kidney failure risk in these countries. The researchers hypothesize that the lower risk in countries outside North America could be because physicians in some countries may be less likely to refer patients for life-extending dialysis or because they may be better at treating kidney disease.
The Canadian tool had been criticized because the model included little data from kidney disease patients of African descent. African-Americans have the highest rates of kidney disease in the United States. Including this population did not change the validity of the tool since it included variables that capture the excess risk, the researchers found.
“We’ve known which were the important tests to consider in determining the risk of kidney failure, but we didn’t know exactly how to put them together and we didn’t have a high level of confidence that this tool could be used widely,” Coresh says. “Now we do.”
The tool, which will be live www.kidneyfailurerisk.com on Jan. 12, can be helpful in managing the kidney disease of those at risk, acting in some cases as a wake-up call to promote better compliance with medication, diet and other lifestyle changes. It also gives patients and physicians time to plan for potential dialysis and/or transplant. People who go on dialysis do better when they can get surgery ahead of time to create a fistula, a connection between an artery and a vein to facilitate the mechanical cleansing process. A fistula takes months to heal before it can be used. If a kidney transplant is looking like a better option, patients can start looking for a potential kidney donor – the wait for a kidney match can take up to 5 years, though patients can move up the list if a friend or loved one donates to them – and make other preparations.
“Dialysis and transplantation are expensive and complicated and take planning,” says study co-author Morgan E. Grams, MD, PhD, a nephrologist and assistant professor of epidemiology at the Bloomberg School. “Knowing ahead of time allows people to consider their options.”
“Multinational assessment of accuracy of equations for predicting risk of kidney failure: a meta-analysis” was written by Navdeep Tangri, MD, PhD; Morgan E. Grams, MD, PhD; Andrew S. Levey, MD; Josef Coresh, MD, PhD; Lawrence Appel, MD; Brad C. Astor, PhD, MPH; Gabriel Chodick, PhD; Allan J. Collins, MD; Ognjenka Djurdjev, MSc; C. Raina Elley, MBCHB, PhD; Marie Evans, MD, PhD; Amit X. Garg, MD, PhD; Stein I. Hallan, MD, PhD; Lesley Inker, MD, MS; Sadayoshi Ito, MD, PhD; Sun Ha Jee, PhD; Csaba P. Kovesdy, MD; Florian Kronenberg, MD; Hiddo J. Lambers Heerspink, PharmD, PhD; Angharad Marks,MBBCh, MRCP, MSc, PhD; Girish N. Nadkarni, MD, MPH; Sankar D. Navaneethan, MD, MPH; Robert G. Nelson, MD, PhD; Stephanie Titze, MD, MSc; Mark J. Sarnak, MD, MS; Benedicte Stengel, MD, PhD; Mark Woodward, PhD and Kunitoshi Iseki, MD, PhD for the Chronic Kidney Disease Prognosis Consortium (CKD-PC).
The CKD-PC Data Coordinating Center is funded in part by a program grant from the U.S. National Kidney Foundation (NKF funding sources include AbbVie, Amgen, and Merck) and the National Institutes of Health’s National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (R01DK100446-01). A variety of sources have supported enrollment and data collection including laboratory measurements, and follow-up in the collaborating cohorts of the CKD-PC. These funding sources include government agencies such as national institutes of health and medical research councils as well as foundations and industry sponsors.